I would much rather have a PG who is a liability on the offensive end than the defensive end. Look at Rondo. Like Rondo, Kidd's defense makes the teams offense so much easier. You guys are seriously underrating Kidd on the defensive side of the ball and his leadership. Also, two can play the game you are playing with your last statement: "Besides if you have Shaq, Duncan, LeBron, Kobe in their prime, all who have the ability to create their own shot, on the same team, you can afford to have a weak link offensively."