Jason Kidd overrated? In my opinion Nash is overrated. Nash defensively blows, he has a career dRTG of 110, while Kidd rests at a 102. Don't believe in advanced stats? Even the normal stats prove Kidd has the edge. Now, there is more to comparing then stats yes, but Kidd takes over here. APG Kidd - 9.2 Nash - 8.3 Kidd has a steady lead there, although I will admit Nash is the better "clutch" or "legit" passer out of these two guys. Scoring wise, it's safe to say Kidd isn't that accurate, but he puts up the points his team needs him to put up, averaging 13.6 PPG Career (Nash 14.6) Bottom line is, defense always takes the edge when comparing players, and the fact that Nash could shoot better just doesn't make up for the fact he can't play on his man.