The My QB is better than yours! Thread

[Smitty]

All this talk and no mention of the phenom Jared Lorenzen?

[Paul]

Really they have Tom Brady at a 95? And Matt Schaub at 89? Where is Matt Ryan by chance?

[fish7718]

Dude, he's won one playoff game in 4 years as a starter. If that doesn't scream winner then what does?

Manning won 0 playoff games in 4 years as a starter...your point?

[EastCoastNiner]

I still don't get what is with the Tony Romo hate.

 

1. There are supporters of Eli Manning in here who did pretty much nothing in the most important game of his career and had his defense and a miraculous catch bail him out.

 

That's not to mention his crazy salary.

 

 

2. Supporters' of Donvan McNabb who is perhaps the biggest choker in the NFL. He may have made the NFC Championship five times, but the fact remains he lost four of them, and lost in the Super Bowl, so it's funny giving Tony Romo [expletive] when he isn't on nearly the same choke level as him.

 

3. How many playoff games has Aaron Rogers won?

 

He played well, but he still lost.

[NomarFachix]

1. There are supporters of Eli Manning in here who did pretty much nothing in the most important game of his career and had his defense and a miraculous catch bail him out.

 

That's not to mention his crazy salary.

 

19/34 255 Yards 2 TD 1 INT > 29/48 266 Yards 1 TD 0 INT > Nothing

 

56% Completion, 250+ Yards and a 2:1 TD/INT ratio is pretty good in a Super Bowl against the #4 ranked defense in the league that year, I'd say.

 

Is his salary high? Sure. Inflation, the next 5 contracts given out to franchise QBs will be similar/higher.

[Lkr]

Really they have Tom Brady at a 95? And Matt Schaub at 89? Where is Matt Ryan by chance?

He's not a winner like Tony Romo, sorry

[Flash]

I still don't get what is with the Tony Romo hate.

 

1. There are supporters of Eli Manning in here who did pretty much nothing in the most important game of his career and had his defense and a miraculous catch bail him out.

 

That's not to mention his crazy salary.

 

 

2. Supporters' of Donvan McNabb who is perhaps the biggest choker in the NFL. He may have made the NFC Championship five times, but the fact remains he lost four of them, and lost in the Super Bowl, so it's funny giving Tony Romo [expletive] when he isn't on nearly the same choke level as him.

 

3. How many playoff games has Aaron Rogers won?

 

He played well, but he still lost.

Rodgers made the playoffs and is the only reason GB was in that game against the defending NFC champs. Not his fault the defense choked that day.

 

Romo doesn't suck but Fish overrates him way too much.

 

ECN, who are you taking? Rodgers or Romo?

[Big Penny]

http://www.everyjoe.com/emqb/files/2009/01/joe-flacco_upiphotos896630-nfl-week-11-ravens.jpg

 

the ultimate winner. end of discussion.

[BasX]

http://www.everyjoe.com/emqb/files/2009/01/joe-flacco_upiphotos896630-nfl-week-11-ravens.jpg

the ultimate winner. end of discussion.

Lol no

[Big Penny]

Lol no

http://img223.imageshack.us/img223/8076/raylewiswacko0.png

[Flash]

If you want a "winner" then this is your guy:

 

http://images.starpulse.com/pictures/2009/01/14/previews/Ben%20Roethlisberger%20%287%29-IOS-010623.jpg

 

Rape and all..

[EastCoastNiner]

http://www.everyjoe.com/emqb/files/2009/01/joe-flacco_upiphotos896630-nfl-week-11-ravens.jpg

 

the ultimate winner. end of discussion.

 

He's not that good of a QB, and will be exposed in the coming years if he even lasts a few more years.

 

OVER-RATED!

[Warren2ThaG]

Elisabeth Hasselbeck

 

http://www.watchingtheview.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/elisabeth-hasselbeck-us-weekly-25-most-stylish-2.jpg

[Big Penny]

He's not that good of a QB, and will be exposed in the coming years if he even lasts a few more years.

 

OVER-RATED!

lolololololooloolololol

http://i296.photobucket.com/albums/mm167/djkazz505/HiHaterLogocopy.png

exposed in the coming years? guy was throwing to a bad WRs (other than D-Mase) and was still considered OK. Joe is gonna beast it next season.

Edited May 2, 2010 by UnoCinco

[fish7718]

19/34 255 Yards 2 TD 1 INT > 29/48 266 Yards 1 TD 0 INT > Nothing

 

56% Completion, 250+ Yards and a 2:1 TD/INT ratio is pretty good in a Super Bowl against the #4 ranked defense in the league that year, I'd say.

 

Is his salary high? Sure. Inflation, the next 5 contracts given out to franchise QBs will be similar/higher.

He had a good playoffs that year and I won't doubt that, even though you can relate a lot of success to the defense that kept him in good field situations and made it so he didn't have to take chances but to wait for more opportunities but that was smart he played within himself. When push comes to shove Manning is not much more than above average QB who played over his head in one playoff series.

[NomarFachix]

He had a good playoffs that year and I won't doubt that, even though you can relate a lot of success to the defense that kept him in good field situations and made it so he didn't have to take chances but to wait for more opportunities but that was smart he played within himself. When push comes to shove Manning is not much more than above average QB who played over his head in one playoff series.

 

You can make whatever excuses that you want to discredit Manning, just because you're a Romo fanboy.

 

http://i43.tinypic.com/6nqdli.jpg

 

http://i44.tinypic.com/2rr88jo.jpg

[fish7718]

You can make whatever excuses that you want to discredit Manning, just because you're a Romo fanboy.

 

http://i43.tinypic.com/6nqdli.jpg

 

http://i44.tinypic.com/2rr88jo.jpg

Posting pictures does not make your point, my post was completely factual and a lot of people would agree with me including probably you and you prove that by not arguing the points I made but just posting pictures and calling me a romo fanboy. 8-8, 11-5, stop living in the past.

[fly3rs18]

romo sucks, but romo>eli

 

 

and to all of eli's gay lovers, no one cares that eli won one superbowl, congrats giants defense on that one. if your argument of why eli is good is that he won a superbowl, then you also have to argue that brad johnson is a much better quarterback then donovan mcnabb. johnson has more rings right?

Edited May 3, 2010 by fly3rs18

[NomarFachix]

Posting pictures does not make your point, my post was completely factual and a lot of people would agree with me including probably you and you prove that by not arguing the points I made but just posting pictures and calling me a romo fanboy. 8-8, 11-5, stop living in the past.

 

You posted facts? I was 100% certain that those were opinions... but alright, bud.

 

93.1 QB Rating

4021 Yards

27 TD

14 INT

62.3 Completion %

 

Which one of those is average? I'll wait for your sidestepping deflection while you take the argument in another, unrelated direction.

[NomarFachix]

romo sucks, but romo>eli

 

 

and to all of eli's gay lovers, no one cares that eli won one superbowl, congrats giants defense on that one. if your argument of why eli is good is that he won a superbowl, then you also have to argue that brad johnson is a much better quarterback then donovan mcnabb. johnson has more rings right?

 

My argument for Eli being good is his play on the field... lol. You make a compelling argument saying that both Romo and Manning suck, Eli has gay lovers, etc. etc. etc. Hard not to take you seriously.

 

PS - Every Giants fan in the country cares that Eli won a superbowl as the MVP and led a game winning drive in the 4th against the 4th ranked NFL defense and left the Pats with under a minute on the clock. Sorry that Eagles and Cowboys fans don't, but I call that sour grapes.

[fish7718]

You posted facts? I was 100% certain that those were opinions... but alright, bud.

 

93.1 QB Rating

4021 Yards

27 TD

14 INT

62.3 Completion %

 

Which one of those is average? I'll wait for your sidestepping deflection while you take the argument in another, unrelated direction.

 

The 8-8 record

 

Of course we can't overlook the 79.2 career QB rating

[NomarFachix]

 

The 8-8 record

 

Of course we can't overlook the 79.2 career QB rating

 

I was right on the money with the sidestepping.

 

You're saying that the Giants went 8-8 because of Eli Manning? With their void of defense, a regressing offensive line, and non-existent running game, Eli Manning is the main reason the Giants won 8 games.

 

So we live in the present and call the Giants an 8-8 team and disregard their SB victory (and beating the Cowboys in the process), but we bring up career stats and not simply the stats from last year? Pick a direction, dude, and try to stick with it.

Edited May 3, 2010 by Bounding and Astounding

[fish7718]

I was right on the money with the sidestepping.

 

You're saying that the Giants went 8-8 because of Eli Manning? With their void of defense, a regressing offensive line, and non-existent running game, Eli Manning is the main reason the Giants won 8 games.

 

So we live in the present and call the Giants an 8-8 team and disregard their SB victory (and beating the Cowboys in the process), but we bring up career stats and not simply the stats from last year? Pick a direction, dude, and try to stick with it.

My direction is that Manning is nothing more than an above average QB his stats are jacked up because of big games against the Raiders, Chiefs, etc..I'll admit he had a good year last year too but I'm not ready to say hes a great QB now -- good/above average until he proves for 2 straight years that he is deserving

Edited May 3, 2010 by Fish7718

[Flash]

My direction is that Manning is nothing more than an above average QB his stats are jacked up because of big games against the Raiders, Chiefs, etc..I'll admit he had a good year last year too but I'm not ready to say hes a great QB now -- good/above average until he proves for 2 straight years that he is deserving

 

So you crown Romo for being "a winner" but Manning has won more playoff games and won a Superbowl. Whether or not he played a great game doesn't matter. He led them down the field for the winning TD.

[fish7718]

So you crown Romo for being "a winner" but Manning has won more playoff games and won a Superbowl. Whether or not he played a great game doesn't matter. He led them down the field for the winning TD.

I'm not going to go into this because it's not even worth it, Manning's ability does not equal Romo's, simple as that. Romo has a better career record, yes Manning got hot at the right time, Romo hasn't. Still believe Romo > Rodgers >>>>> Manning.